A deletion/insertion polymorphism in the transcriptional control region of the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTTLPR) was reported to be associated with dimensional measures of neuroticism, although subsequent replication attempts have failed. These replication attempts, however, have been dissimilar to the initial study in sample size, distribution of allelic frequency and/or assessment of neuroticism. The current study was conducted in a further attempt to replicate the initial finding using: (a) a sample that was more comparable to each of the individual samples in the initial report; and (b) identical psychometric methodology to assess neuroticism. Two hundred and twenty-five Caucasian adults were genotyped for the 5-HTTLPR polymorphism and completed the NEO Personality Inventory. Results did not replicate the association between the 5-HTTLPR polymorphism and neuroticism; individuals with the short form of this variant did not report higher NEO Neuroticism. Indeed, men with the short form reported lower Anxiety, a finding that is directionally opposite to the initial results. These findings, combined with other failures to replicate, indicate that the reproducibility of the association between the 5-HTTLPR polymorphism and neuroticism must be regarded as questionable. The contradictory findings suggest the need for a replication attempt in a large, normative sample that is stratified by ethnicity and sex.