Calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) and amylin are homologous 37-amino-acid peptides which have been demonstrated to have anabolic effects on bone. It is not clear whether these effects are mediated by a common receptor, nor is it known which ligand is the more potent. These questions are addressed in the present study using cultures of fetal rat osteoblasts. CGRP increased cell number when present in a concentration >/=10-9 M, but 10-8 M CGRP was required to stimulate thymidine and phenylalanine incorporation. Amylin was effective on these indices at 100-fold lower concentrations, and its maximal effects were about twice as great as those of CGRP. ED50's for the effects of amylin and CGRP on cell number were 10-12 M and 10-10 M, respectively. There was no additivity between maximal doses of the peptides on these indices. The effects of specific receptor blockers on the maximal stimulation of cell number by these peptides were also studied. The CGRP receptor-blocker, CGRP-(8-37), completely blocked the effect of CGRP at blocker concentrations >/=10-9 M. In contrast, the amylin receptor blocker, amylin-(8-37), completely blocked the effects of CGRP when the blocker was present in concentrations as low as 10-11 M. The KI of CGRP-(8-37) was 2 x 10-10 M and that of amylin-(8-37) was 7 x 10-12 M. In converse experiments studying the blockade of maximal doses of amylin, amylin-(8-37) 10-10 M was effective (KI 1 x 10-10 M), whereas a 100-fold greater concentration of CGRP-(8-37) was necessary to achieve the same effect (KI 6 x 10-9 M). It is concluded that amylin and CGRP probably act through a common receptor to stimulate osteoblast growth, and that this receptor has a higher affinity for amylin than for CGRP.