The reaction dynamics of phenyl radicals (C6H5) with ethylene (C2H4) and D4-ethylene (C2D4) were investigated at two collision energies of 83.6 and 105.3 kJ mol-1 utilizing a crossed molecular beam setup. The experiments suggested that the reaction followed indirect scattering dynamics via complex formation and was initiated by an addition of the phenyl radical to the carbon-carbon double bond of the ethylene molecule forming a C6H5CH2CH2 radical intermediate. Under single collision conditions, this short-lived transient species was found to undergo unimolecular decomposition via atomic hydrogen loss through a tight exit transitions state to synthesize the styrene molecule (C6H5C2H3). Experiments with D4-ethylene verified that in the corresponding reaction with ethylene the hydrogen atom was truly emitted from the ethylene unit but not from the phenyl moiety. The overall reaction to form styrene plus atomic hydrogen from the reactants was found to be exoergic by 25 +/- 12 kJ mol(-1). This study provides solid evidence that in combustion flames the styrene molecule, a crucial precursor to form polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), can be formed within a single neutral-neutral collision, a long-standing theoretical prediction which has remained to be confirmed by laboratory experiments under well-defined single collision conditions for the last 50 years.