The concept of a truly innovative "neurology" journal germinated in the mind of Clarence Luther Herrick and then flowered, in March of 1891, as the first issue of Volume 1 of The Journal of Comparative Neurology. The other parts appeared in June, October, and December of the same year. The contributors to this volume, and their affiliations, were: C.L. Herrick (University of Cincinnati-UC), C.H. Turner (UC), B.G. Wilder (Cornell), F.W. Langdon (Miami Medical College, Cincinnati), C.J. Herrick (UC) H.R. Pemberton (Princeton), T.B. Stowell (State Normal and Training School, Potsdam), and O.S. Strong of Columbia who translated a large paper by Carl von Kupffer, the famous German anatomist. In 1890-91 some of these scientists (e.g., Wilder, Langdon, Stowell, von Kupffer) were well known and had already made notable contributions in their chosen fields. However, several were students (e.g., Turner, C.J. Herrick, Pemberton, Strong), most of whom would make important contributions in later years. The founder of JCN, Clarence Luther Herrick, by 1891 had an excellent reputation in geology and natural science and had already established a successful scientific journal. Based on the totality of their contributions, the authors of the papers that made up Volume 1 of JCN were a unique group. Textbooks that went through several editions came from Wilder, C.J. Herrick, and Strong; the latter is currently going into its 9th edition. Structures were named in recognition of the original descriptions by von Kupffer and C.L. Herrick, a type of insect behavior recognized Turner's discovery, and after their deaths several had university buildings, one a scientific club, and one a research award, named in their honor. There were also interesting and important links between these nine men. Turner and C.J. Herrick were students of C.L. Herrick, and Stowell served as a member of the Association of American Anatomists nomenclature committee which was chaired by Wilder. C.J. Herrick became a student (for his Ph.D.) of Strong's, and Strong became an associate editor of JCN under C.J. Herrick. Of the nine, two practiced medicine; Langdon in an academic setting, Pemberton in private practice. The lives of the nine scientists whose work made up Volume 1 of JCN are reviewed. Many of these individuals were notable, not only for their work in the first volume of JCN, but for their larger and enduring contributions in the biomedical sciences.