Melanins are ubiquitous in nature but their biological activities and functions have been difficult to discern. Conventional approaches to determine material function start by resolving structure and then characterize relevant properties. These approaches have been less successful for melanins because of their complex structure and insolubility, and because their relevant properties are not readily characterized by conventional methods. Here, we report a novel spectroelectrochemical reverse engineering approach that focuses on redox and radical scavenging activities. In this method, the melanin is immobilized in a permeable hydrogel film adjacent to an electrode and this immobilized melanin is probed using diffusible mediators and complex electrical inputs. Response characteristics are measured using two modalities, electrochemical currents associated with the reaction of diffusible mediators, and optical absorbance associated with the presence of diffusible free radicals. Using this method, we observed that both Sepia and fungal melanins are redox active and can repeatedly exchange electrons to be switched between oxidized and reduced states. Further, we observed that these melanins can quench radicals either by donating or accepting electrons. Finally, we demonstrate that the melanins' radical scavenging activities are dependent on their redox state such that a melanin must be reduced to have donatable electrons to quench oxidative free radicals, or must be oxidized to accept electrons from reductive free radicals. While the observation that melanin is redox-active is consistent with their well-accepted beneficial (radical-scavenging) and detrimental (pro-oxidant) activities, these observations may also support less well-accepted proposed functions for melanin in energy harvesting and redox communication.