A 313 plastome phylogenomic analysis of Pooideae: Exploring relationships among the largest subfamily of grasses

Abstract

In this study, we analyzed 313 plastid genomes (plastomes) of Poaceae with a focus on expanding our current knowledge of relationships among the subfamily Pooideae, which represented over half the dataset (164 representatives). In total, 47 plastomes were sequenced and assembled for this study. This is the largest study of its kind to include plastome-level data, to not only increase sampling at both the taxonomic and molecular levels with the aim of resolving complex and reticulate relationships, but also to analyze the effects of alignment gaps in large-scale analyses, as well as explore divergences in the subfamily with an expanded set of 14 accepted grass fossils for more accurate calibrations and dating. Incorporating broad systematic assessments of Pooideae taxa conducted by authors within the last five years, we produced a robust phylogenomic reconstruction for the subfamily, which included all but two supergeneric taxa (Calothecinae and Duthieeae). We further explored how including alignment gaps in plastome analyses oftentimes can produce incorrect or misinterpretations of complex or reticulate relationships among taxa of Pooideae. This presented itself as consistently changing relationships at specific nodes for different stripping thresholds (percentage-based removal of gaps per alignment column). Our summary recommendation for large-scale genomic plastome datasets is to strip alignment columns of all gaps to increase pairwise identity and reduce errant signal from poly A/T bias. To do this we used the "mask alignment" tool in Geneious software. Finally, we determined an overall divergence age for Pooideae of roughly 84.8 Mya, which is in line with, but slightly older than most recent estimates.

Keywords: BOP; Chloroplast; Divergence; Genome; Plastome; Pooideae.