Vexing visits: Variables correlating with physician perceptions of patients as "difficult" and overall enjoyment of their delivery of primary ambulatory care

Int J Psychiatry Med. 2021 Sep;56(5):354-363. doi: 10.1177/00912174211032037. Epub 2021 Aug 1.

Abstract

All physicians experience some patients described as "difficult." Their prevalence negatively impacts work satisfaction. Prior research identified factors present when physicians perceive patients as difficult. Numerous variables are unrelated to vexing patient visits. Three additive patient characteristics predict difficult encounters: 1) depressive or anxiety comorbidity, 2) polysymptomatic patients, and 3) high symptom severity. The sole physician variable was their score on the Physician Belief Scale (PBS) which quantifies negative attitudes towards psychosocial problems. When all three patient predictors exist, high PBS scorers judge twice as many patients as difficult. Five clinic milieu variables correlated weakly with clinic satisfaction among primary care residents. They are: 1) minimal role conflict, 2) autonomy, 3) collegiality, 4) encouragement of professional growth, and 5) work group loyalty. "Positive affect" was among the strongest physician variables but the author labeled it a confounding variable. Finally, a small "n" QI study conducted in this author's residency explored the role of physician affectivity and identified additional physician characteristics and clinic milieu factors correlating with overall enjoyment of ambulatory clinic practice. Surprisingly, none of the five previously identified clinic milieu variables correlated directly with resident clinic satisfaction. "Supportive staff cohesion" was one milieu variable that correlated significantly with clinic satisfaction. Resident affective characteristics that significantly reduced clinic satisfaction were "hostility" and "negative affectivity." "Joviality" was positively related to clinic satisfaction. While patient variables are uncontrollable, it is plausible that by physicians changing their beliefs and affectivity the percentage of vexing visits could be cut in half improving work satisfaction.

Keywords: affectivity; difficult patients; physician beliefs; physician satisfaction; primary care.

MeSH terms

  • Ambulatory Care
  • Humans
  • Patient Satisfaction
  • Perception
  • Physician-Patient Relations
  • Physicians*
  • Pleasure*
  • Primary Health Care