We demonstrate that the Halorhodospira halophila (Hhal) photoactive yellow protein (PYP) is not representative of the greater PYP family. The photodynamics of the PYP isolated from Salinibacter ruber (Srub) is characterized with a comprehensive range of spectroscopic techniques including ultrafast transient absorption, photostationary light titrations, Fourier transform infrared, and cryokinetics spectroscopies. We demonstrate that the dark-adapted pG state consists of two subpopulations differing in the protonation state of the chromophore and that both are photoactive, with the protonated species undergoing excited-state proton transfer. However, the primary I0 photoproduct observed in the Hhal PYP photocycle is absent in the Srub PYP photodynamics, which indicates that this intermediate, while important in Hhal photodynamics, is not a critical intermediate in initiating all PYP photocycles. The excited-state lifetime of Srub PYP is the longest of any PYP resolved to date (∼30 ps), which we ascribe to the more constrained chromophore binding pocket of Srub PYP and the absence of the critical Arg52 residue found in Hhal PYP. The final stage of the Srub PYP photocycle involves the slowest known thermal dark reversion of a PYP (∼40 min vs 350 ms in Hhal PYP). This property allowed the characterization of a pH-dependent equilibrium between the light-adapted pB state with a protonated cis chromophore and a newly resolved pG' intermediate with a deprotonated cis chromophore and pG-like protein conformation. This result demonstates that protein conformational changes and chromophore deprotonation precede chromophore reisomerization during the thermal recovery of the PYP photocycle.