Concomitant Identification of Muddy Brown Granular Casts and Low Fractional Excretion of Urinary Sodium in AKI

Abstract

Background: Fractional excretion of urinary sodium (FENa) is a widely utilized clinical test to evaluate acute kidney injury (AKI). A low FENa (<1%) is deemed consistent with prerenal azotemia and inconsistent with acute tubular injury (ATI). Muddy brown granular casts (MBGC) on microscopic examination of urinary sediment (MicrExUrSed) are highly suggestive of ATI. We hypothesized that there is poor concordance between the presence of MBGC and FENa in ATI.

Methods: We conducted a prospective observational study in patients with AKI seen during inpatient consultation. We extracted patients who underwent assessment of percentage of low power fields (LPFs) with MBGC by MicrExUrSed and concomitant measurement of FENa. Diagnostic concordance between MBGC and FENa and their individual prognostic value were examined.

Results: Our cohort included 270 patients, 111 (41%) of whom were women. Median age was 61 years (range 27-92 years), and median serum creatinine was 3.7 mg/dl ( range1.2-22.0 mg/dl). MBGC were found in 49% (133/270). FENa <1% (inconsistent with ATI) was found in 50/133 (38%), 38/115 (33%), and 16/45 (36%) of those with >0%, ≥10%, and ≥50% LPFs with MBGC, respectively. Concordance between FENa and MBGC for ATI diagnosis was deemed fair (estimated κ-coefficient=0.2), and poor (κ=-0.11) within a subgroup of patients with preexisting chronic kidney disease (n=139). In patients with biopsy-proven ATI (n=49), MBGC had 100% specificity and 100% positive predictive value for ATI. MBGC were associated with greater risk for ≥50% increase in creatinine from baseline at discharge (acute kidney disease [AKD]).

Conclusions: About two of five patients with MBGC identified by MicrExUrSed presented with FENa <1%. Presence of MBGC was consistent with ATI, as verified by biopsy, and were predictive of AKD. These data suggest that the sole reliance in low FENa to exclude ATI should be abandoned, and MicrExUrSed should be pursued for AKI diagnosis.

Keywords: acute kidney injury; acute kidney injury and ICU nephrology; acute tubular injury; acute tubular necrosis; fractional excretion of sodium; muddy brown granular cast; urinary casts; urine microscopy; urine sediment.