Phosphorylation of proteins by kinase enzymes is a post-translational modification involved in a myriad of biological events, including cell signaling and disease development. Identifying the interactions between a kinase and its phosphorylated substrate(s) is necessary to characterize phosphorylation-mediated cellular events and encourage development of kinase-targeting drugs. One method for substrate-kinase identification utilizes photocrosslinking γ-phosphate-modified ATP analogues to covalently link kinases to their substrates for subsequent monitoring. Because photocrosslinking ATP analogues require UV light, which could influence cell biology, we report here two ATP analogues, ATP-aryl fluorosulfate (ATP-AFS) and ATP-hexanoyl bromide (ATP-HexBr), that crosslink kinase-substrate pairs via proximity-mediated reactions without the need for UV irradiation. Both ATP-AFS and ATP-HexBr acted as cosubstrates with a variety of kinases for affinity-based crosslinking, with ATP-AFS showing more robust complexes. Importantly, ATP-AFS promoted crosslinking in lysates, which demonstrates compatibility with complex cellular mixtures for future application to kinase-substrate identification.