The α-helical coiled coil (CC) is one of the best-characterized folding motifs in the protein world. In this context, fluorinated amino acids have been shown to be capable of tuning the properties of CC assemblies, and especially fluorinated derivatives of aliphatic amino acids can significantly increase the stability of this folding motif when placed in the hydrophobic a and d positions. However, it has not been shown yet whether fluorinated amino acids, by means of rational design, can be used as an orthogonal tool to control CC assembly processes. In the current work, we approached this question by creating a combinatorial peptide library based on a VPE/VPK heteromeric CC system previously established and characterized in our group. This CC model allowed us to screen fluorinated amino acids for interaction with different potential binding partners in position a of the VPE/VPK model with a particular emphasis on studying the impact of stereochemistry within the side chain of α-branched aliphatic fluorinated amino acids on CC properties such as oligomerization state, thermodynamic stability, and orientation. 28 combinations of library members were characterized regarding structure, oligomerization, and thermal stability utilizing circular dichroism, size exclusion chromatography, and Förster resonance energy transfer measurements. This detailed approach showed that the stability and oligomerization state of the motif were not only dependent on the steric demand and the fluorination of corresponding amino acids but also on the stereochemistry within the side chain. The results were applied for a rational design of the fluorine-driven orthogonal assembly, and we could show that CC dimer formation occurred based on specific interactions between fluorinated amino acids. These results demonstrate the potential of fluorinated amino acids as an orthogonal tool besides classical electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions for the fine-tuning and direction of peptide-peptide interactions. Furthermore, within the space of fluorinated amino acids, we could demonstrate the specificity of interactions between differently fluorinated side chains.