Comparison of Ureteral Stent Biomaterials: Encrustation Profile in Lithogenic Artificial Urine Models

Yi X Wu; Eric J Choi; Amberly A Vu; Pengbo Jiang; Sohrab N Ali; Roshan M Patel; Jaime Landman; Ralph V Clayman

doi:10.1021/acsomega.3c01800

Comparison of Ureteral Stent Biomaterials: Encrustation Profile in Lithogenic Artificial Urine Models

ACS Omega. 2023 Aug 1;8(32):29003-29011. doi: 10.1021/acsomega.3c01800. eCollection 2023 Aug 15.

Authors

Yi X Wu¹, Eric J Choi², Amberly A Vu¹, Pengbo Jiang¹, Sohrab N Ali¹, Roshan M Patel¹, Jaime Landman¹, Ralph V Clayman¹

Affiliations

¹ Department of Urology, University of California, Irvine, Orange 92868, California, United States.
² Department of Chemistry, University of California, Irvine, Irvine 92697, California, United States.

Abstract

Ureteral stent encrustation significantly limits indwelling time and can lead to downstream urological problems. However, no ideal polymeric biomaterials have been shown to completely resist encrustation in long-term urine exposure. Recently, 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA)-coated Pellethane was reported as a promising biomaterial resistant to encrustation. This study compared HEMA-coated Pellethane to commercially available stents under two different artificial urine environments. To evaluate the degree and composition of encrustation on HEMA-coated Pellethane, Boston Scientific Tria, Bard InLay Optima, Cook Universa Hydrogel, and Cook Black Silicone stents were used at various dwelling times in two different artificial urine environments. In a batch-flow model, samples of stents were suspended in an artificial urine solution (AUS) at 37 °C. Every 24 h for 11 weeks, 50% of the AUS would be replaced with fresh components using a programmable peristaltic pump system. The stent materials were removed at suitable time intervals and air-dried for 24 h under sterile conditions before follow-up analysis. SEM was used to assess the degree of encrustation, and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) was employed to quantify the encrusted compositions, specifically for calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus. We measured the weight gain over time due to encrusted deposits on the stents and quantified the amount of Ca, Mg, and P deposited on each encrusted stent. After the 11 week trial, HEMA-coated Pellethane showed the most average mass change. SEM showed that HEMA-coated Pellethane was fully encrusted in just 2 weeks in the AUS environments, and ICP-MS showed that Ca is the most abundant deposit. Among all the tested stents, Black Silicone performed the best. The two AUSs were formulated to encrust more rapidly than physiological conditions. HEMA-coated Pellethane is not an ideal stent material, while silicone is a promising material for advancing ureteral stents.