Polarized Fourier transform infrared (p-FTIR) spectroscopy is a widely used technique for determining orientational information in thin organic materials. Conventionally, a single polarizer is placed in the path of the incident light (termed the polarizer). Occasionally, a second polarizer is also placed after the sample (referred to as the analyzer). However, this polarizer-analyzer configuration has the potential to induce polarization-dependent variances in the final spectra beyond those that are expected, i.e., the squared-cosine relationship of absorptance with respect to polarization angle is no longer accurate. These variances are due to changes in the polarization state of the transmitted light induced by the sample and have yet to be explored in the context of p-FTIR. Consequently, this study employs both theoretical and experimental approaches to identify the effects of including a second polarizer in p-FTIR analyses of anisotropic organic samples. For thin samples, the most significant spectral variance arising from only birefringence is observed on the shoulders of the dichroic peaks. By adopting a crossed polarizer configuration, it is shown that there is potential to identify anisotropy of samples that are generally considered too thick for p-FTIR analysis by exploiting this feature. Furthermore, the squared-cosine relationship of absorptance with respect to the polarization angle is also shown to be inapplicable when a second parallel-oriented polarizer is included. Accordingly, a function that accounts for the second polarizer is proposed for multiple polarization techniques.