An 89-year-old woman presented with chronic pain and foreign body sensation in a healthy-appearing anophthalmic socket. Computed tomography of the orbits showed hyperdense, cystic lesions superior and posterior to the orbital implant. Orbital exploration was performed; the orbital implant and lesions were removed. Histopathology revealed cystic structures composed of fibrocellular tissue lined with histiocytes and multinucleated giant cells, consistent with pseudocysts. Postoperatively, the patient noted the resolution of her symptoms. While the etiology of the pseudocysts remains unclear, we hypothesize that the answer can be traced back to the original surgery. The cysts may have formed after extravasation of fluid or proteinaceous material from the eye, from glycerin on the donor sclera, or after introduction of foreign material during retrobulbar injection of local anesthesia. This is the first report of pseudocysts occurring in the orbit posterior to an implant.