Phagocytosis of opsonized particles by neutrophils and monocytes plays a central role in host defense mechanisms against foreign pathogens. This process depends on the interaction between C3bi, a degradation product derived from activation of the complement system, and the alpha M beta 2 (CD11b/CD18, Mac-1) receptor, the major integrin on neutrophils. Previous studies had established a central role for the I domain, a stretch of approximately 200 amino acids within the alpha M subunit in the binding of C3bi, as well as many other alpha M beta 2 ligands. The present study was undertaken to establish the molecular basis of C3bi recognition by alpha M beta 2. The strategy employed the use of a series of mutant receptors in which short segments of the I domain of alpha M were switched to the corresponding segments of alpha L, which is structurally very similar but does not bind C3bi. We report three major findings: (1) The C3bi binding pocket is composed of three regions, P147-R152, P201-K217, and K245-R261 of alpha M, which surround the cation binding site within the MIDAS motif of the I domain. (2) Within the latter segment, K245 plays a critical role in mediating C3bi binding to alpha M beta 2. Mutation of K245 to Ala significantly reduced C3bi binding but had no effect on binding of another alpha M beta 2 I domain ligand, NIF. (3) Blocking of C3bi binding to alpha M beta 2 by monoclonal antibodies is achieved through two different mechanisms: direct competition for the ligand binding site or induction of conformational changes. Overall, these studies support the hypothesis that many of the ligands of alpha M beta 2 bind to overlapping but not identical sites within the I domain. Although the same short structural segments within the I domain may be involved in binding, different amino acids within these segments may contact different ligands.