The value of extended transurethral resection of bladder tumour (TURBT) in the treatment of bladder cancer

Abstract

Transurethral resection of bladder tumour (TURBT) is the 'gold standard' in the diagnosis and therapy of non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer. To improve the quality of this technique an additional TUR (after 4-6 weeks) or a simultaneous photodynamic diagnosis is often offered. The present study shows different variables that influence, to a greater or lesser extent, the accuracy of the TUR diagnosis and the success of the operation. This is very important for the further management of bladder cancer, be it in tumour follow-up or in preparation for more invasive therapies.

Objective: To analyse the impact of a standardised extended transurethral resection of bladder tumour (TURBT) protocol on the determination of the residual tumour status at initial TURBT session and recurrence rate in the primary resection area. Despite, the fact that there is a clear consensus on the aims of TURBT, there is little agreement on how to perform TURBT to achieve that goal.

Patients and methods: We retrospectively evaluated 221 consecutive patients, who underwent 305 TURBT sessions for bladder cancer, including patients with recurrent tumours. All the TURBTs were extended by taking additional deep and marginal specimens, according to a standardised protocol. Clinical and histopathological data were retrieved from the patients' records.

Results: Across all tumour stages, residual tumour (pR1) was found in 38% of the additionally taken specimens. There was a significant association of pR1 status with tumour stage, grade, and size. Also in the group of non-muscle-invading tumours, the rate of R1 resection was rather high at 22%. There was no association with focality and the training status of the surgeon. At follow-up, of all the patients with a unifocal primary tumour there was recurrence in the same area as the primary in 5.1%.

Conclusions: Extended TURBT provides detailed information about the horizontal and vertical extent of the bladder tumour. The implementation of standardised TURBT procedures, such as our protocol of an extended TURBT, is greatly needed to improve local tumour control. Whether a diagnostic re-TUR may be restricted to those cases with positive margins or ground specimens remains to be studied.