The dysplastic nevus in nonfamilial melanoma is a clinicopathologic entity consistently demonstrating an eightfold or greater association with malignant melanoma. The present report quantifies the relationship between nuclear atypia and 16 architectural and cytoplasmic features in 153 pigmented nevi removed from a similar number of patients with newly diagnosed nonfamilial melanoma. All lesions were evaluated by one dermatopathologist, and most lesions were reviewed by a second dermatopathologist. Nuclear atypia of nevomelanocytes was defined as at least three of the following: nuclear enlargement, pleomorphism, hyperchromatism, and prominent nucleoli easily observed throughout each lesion. Seventeen percent of the total nevi had such atypia. On univariate analysis, 11 parameters (lentiginous hyperplasia of the epidermis, basal melanocytic hyperplasia, junctional nest disarray, fusion [bridging] of theques, suprabasal melanocytes, lymphoid response, prominent vascularity, fibroplasia, abundant cytoplasm, "dusty" cytoplasm, and large melanin granules) showed an association with nuclear atypia (P less than .05). However, on multivariate analysis only five parameters continued to be important: basal melanocytic hyperplasia, junctional nest disarray, melanophages (inverse correlation), prominent vascularity, and large melanin granules. These data support the idea that multiple histopathologic characteristics, correlating objectively with nuclear atypia, are important for the diagnosis of dysplastic nevi. In our view, the minimal essential histologic criteria for dysplastic nevi based on these findings include nuclear atypia and abnormal patterns of intraepidermal nevomelanocytic proliferation (ie, basal melanocytic hyperplasia and/or junctional nest disarray).