Treatments and Sequelae of Pediatric Pathologic Proximal Femur Fractures Due to Benign Bone Cyst

Abstract

Background: The proximal femur is a common location for pathologic fractures in children, yet there is little published information regarding this injury. The purpose of this study was to investigate the outcomes of pediatric pathologic proximal femur fractures due to benign bone tumors.

Methods: A retrospective review of patients treated for pathologic proximal femur fractures from 2004 to 2018 was conducted. Inclusion criteria were age below 18 years and pathologic proximal femur fracture secondary to a benign bone tumor. Patients were excluded if they had <1 year of follow-up. Medical charts and serial radiographs were reviewed for fracture classification, underlying pathology, treatment, complications, and time to fracture healing.

Results: A total of 14 patients were included. Mean age was 6±3 (3 to 11) years, and mean follow-up was 44±21 (22 to 86) months. Index treatment was spica casting in 9/14 (68%) patients, while 5/14 (32%) were treated with internal fixation. Of the 9 patients initially treated with casting, 22% (2/9) required repeat spica casting at a mean of 0.6 months after index treatment, 67% (6/9) required internal fixation at a mean of 20.3 months after index treatment, and 11% (1/9) did not require revision treatment. Eighty-eight percent (8/9) of patients treated with casting required revision treatment compared with 40% (2/5) of those treated with internal fixation (P=0.05). Nonunion occurred after 1 refracture, malunion with coxa vara occurred in 2 fractures, and the remaining 11/14 (84%) fractures had a union at a mean of 4.9±3.0 months All cases of malunion occurred in patients initially treated nonoperatively. There were 19 distinct complications in 10/14 (71%) patients. The incidence of any revision surgery was 64% (9/14).

Conclusions: In this series, pediatric pathologic proximal femur fractures demonstrated prolonged time to union, high incidence of revision surgery (64%), and substantial complication rate (71%). In children with pathologic proximal femur fractures, treatment with internal fixation is recommended as this series showed a 78% failure rate of initial conservative management.

Level of evidence: Level IV.