Treatment outcomes with benzylpenicillin and non-benzylpenicillin antibiotics, and the performance of the penicillin zone-edge test versus molecular detection of blaZ in penicillin-susceptible Staphylococcus aureus (PSSA) bacteraemia

Abstract

Objectives: The blaZ gene encodes penicillinase, which inactivates penicillin. As there were reports on suboptimal sensitivity for the penicillin zone-edge test, a phenotypic method for blaZ detection, we investigated treatment outcomes in patients with penicillin-susceptible Staphylococcus aureus (PSSA) bacteraemia (phenotypically negative for penicillinase), subjecting isolates to molecular testing for blaZ retrospectively.

Patients and methods: A retrospective cohort study was conducted on 121 patients with a first episode of PSSA bacteraemia from 1 January 2012 to 31 October 2015 at Tan Tock Seng Hospital (TTSH), Singapore. Patients were grouped into IV benzylpenicillin and non-benzylpenicillin groups. The primary outcome was overall treatment failure, defined as either 30 day all-cause mortality and/or 90 day relapse. The penicillin (P10) zone-edge test was repeated on archived PSSA isolates, concurrently with penicillin MIC determination via gradient diffusion and PCR for blaZ.

Results: Among 121 patients, 57 patients (47.1%) received IV benzylpenicillin as the predominant antibiotic. There was no significant difference in overall treatment failure between treatment with the benzylpenicillin [7/57 (12.3%)] versus non-benzylpenicillin groups [12/64 (18.8%)] (P = 0.33) or cloxacillin/cefazolin [6/37 (16.2%)] (P = 0.59). For 112 PSSA isolates available for testing, repeat penicillin zone-edge testing was negative for penicillinase production, corroborating previous results. A single PSSA isolate with a negative penicillin zone-edge test was found to be positive for blaZ.

Conclusions: We found no differences in overall treatment failure between patients with PSSA bacteraemia treated with benzylpenicillin, anti-staphylococcal β-lactams cefazolin/cloxacillin and other antimicrobials, when using the penicillin zone-edge test as the phenotypic method for blaZ screening.