Objective: Alexithymia is characterized by difficulty identifying and/or describing emotions, reduced imaginal processes, and externally oriented thinking. High levels of alexithymia may increase the challenge of supporting individuals with co-occurring depression and hazardous alcohol use. This secondary analysis sought to investigate whether or not alexithymia moderated the outcomes of an online intervention for depression and alcohol use.
Method: As part of a randomized controlled trial, 988 participants were randomly assigned to receive an intervention dually focused on depression and alcohol use, or an intervention only focused on depression. The pre-specified mediation hypothesis was that changes in drinking at 3 months follow-up would effect the association between the intervention and change in depression at 6 months. This secondary analysis extends the investigation by adding alexithymia as a moderator.
Results: The current analysis demonstrated that including alexithymia as a moderator resulted in a conditional direct effect. Specifically, there was an intervention effect where participants who received the combined depression and alcohol intervention had larger improvements in their depression scores at 6 months, but this was only when their alexithymia score at baseline was also high (60.5 or higher).
Conclusion: These results suggest that treatment planning and intervention effectiveness could be informed and optimized by taking alexithymia severity into consideration. This is especially merited as alexithymia can contribute to the weaker therapeutic alliance, more distress and dysphoria, shorter periods of abstinence, and more severe depression, compounding the complexity of supporting individuals with comorbid conditions. More research is needed to systematically investigate these possible modifying effects.
Plain language title: Does difficulty identifying/describing emotions or externally-oriented thinking influence the effectiveness of an intervention among people with both depression and hazardous alcohol use?
Keywords: alexithymia; alexithymie; analyse de modération modérée; brief internet intervention; brève intervention en ligne; comorbidity; consommation d'alcool dangereuse; depression; dépression, comorbidité; hazardous alcohol use; moderated mediation analysis.
In a recent study we recruited participants who were concerned with both their alcohol use and low mood. We provided two different online interventions. Half of the participants received an intervention designed for both concerns and half received an intervention that addressed only depression. We hypothesized that receiving the combined intervention for both concerns would result in greater benefits, however, our results indicated no apparent difference. This analysis uses the same data, but investigated the influences of alexithymia on the effectiveness of the interventions. Alexithymia is defined as having difficulty identifying/describing emotions and/or thinking more about external events than internal feelings. It commonly co-occurs with depression and with hazardous alcohol use and can increase the challenge of supporting individuals with these co-occurring concerns. The results of this analysis showed support for our original hypothesis that participants who received the intervention that addressed both their mood and alcohol concerns had lower depression scores 6-months later, but only among individuals who also had alexithymia scores above 60.5. Taking alexithymia severity into consideration during treatment planning may help optimize the effectiveness of interventions. These results show merit for future research to consider alexithymia as a variable that could potentially impact outcomes among individuals with co-occurring depression and hazardous alcohol use.